Review: Alexandra the Commissar by Another World

Top Comic

Miniature: Alexandra the Commissar
Manufacturer: Another World Miniatures
Price: €7.50 EUR
Material: Metal

Personally, I find it to be a heartening sign that there is a large demand for female miniature options for 40k armies. Many of them run the full gamut between realistic and pinup in terms of design, but on both ends of the spectrum there are some great options. Numerous independent studios have released miniatures to fill this demand, one of whom is Another World Miniatures.

    Parts List:

  1. Body
  2. Right hand with gun
  3. Left arm with Jacket
  4. Left arm (behind back)

One of their entries to this field is Alexandra the Commissar. She’s presented in a military uniform with an open neckline, a large handgun, and 2 left arm options. One simply puts her left arm behind her back while the other has her coat draped over her arm and wearing a gauntlet.

blowoutThe overall quality of this miniature is pretty poor. While the previous figure I reviewed for Another World had great details and was sculpted well, this one, sadly, is not.

All of the details feel muted. The face is poorly constructed with the barest hint of features. The uniform is barren with only the simplest flow added to make it look like fabric. The pistol is a horrendous blank slate of a gun; it’s really nothing more than geometric shapes assembled into a vague futuristic gun-shape.

rough fitThe arm with the draped coat and powerfist is the best looking piece in the kit. The coat has a lot of folds to it along with pockets and lapel. The fist also has some nice bulk to it along with some well-placed rivets that make it look menacing.

Assembly isn’t hard, but it’s ill-defined. The parts don’t go together well. Attaching the gun hand to the wrist should probably be pinned, but the wrist is so small that it will be challenging. The arm-behind-the-back piece was missing a chunk from the top of the shoulder and didn’t fit flush with the body. Either arm option will require a little gap filling.

Middle Comic

Another item of interest is some proportional issues, the biggest of which is the thickness of her calves. They’re far too thin, especially with bulky combat boots. It gives her an odd appearance.

While I do enjoy the idea of this miniature and think the pose has merit, its execution is disappointing.

While doing research to compare against other exemplars, I discovered Statuesque Miniatures who have a number of excellent female miniature options. Their Commissar Vespera Venko is a very good figure that has much better thematic integrity and a more realistic design.

But, if you want a little titillation then there great options from Raging Heroes, Warforge, and others.

On its own merits this miniature is a passable attempt at a female commissar, but there are other miniatures available that bring the concept to life in superior ways.

Bottom Comic

Advertisements

Author: CreganTur

I'm an aspiring writer who has been toiling at his craft for many years in hopes of becoming a published author. I'm also an avid painter of miniature figures and am in the process of creating my own miniatures company.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s